Browsing by Subject "Food pantry"

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1

The dietary quality of food pantry users from a socio-ecological perspective
(2019) Simmet, Anja; Ströbele-Benschop, Nanette
In Germany, around 1.5 Mio people with a low income receive food for a small fee from one of around 940 so-called “Tafel”. In high-income countries like Germany, users of food pantries are a particularly vulnerable population group, as they are characterized by cumulative health risks. They often suffer from food insecurity and from chronic diseases such as hypertension, diabetes mellitus type 2 or obesity. Given that these diseases as well as food insecurity both relate to diet, the dietary quality plays a critical role in the health status of food pantry users. To illustrate the dietary quality and the different levels of factors influencing the dietary quality among food pantry users, this thesis has the following aims: 1. to provide a summary of the scientific evidence about the dietary quality of food pantry users in high-income countries; 2. to provide a summary of the scientific evidence about the nutritional quality of food provided by food pantries in high-income countries; 3. to examine the distribution of Tafel food pantries and food banks and to provide a representative picture of their resources (e.g. food, volunteers etc.), activities (e.g. provided programs) and users in Germany; 4. to examine the distribution of Tafel food pantries and to identify compositional and physical environmental correlates of food pantry use in Berlin. To reach these aims, two systematic reviews were conducted (first and second publication). In addition, an explorative cross-sectional study consisting of an analysis of secondary data and a comprehensive survey among all Tafel belonging to the federal association “Tafel Deutschland” was performed (third publication). Finally, an ecological study was conducted by analyzing and mapping food pantry use and compositional and physical characteristics of areas in Berlin (fourth publication). The first review revealed that the dietary quality among the reviewed food pantry users tended to be low as reflected by an inadequate intake of energy, fruit and vegetables, dairy products and calcium compared to national recommendations. The reviewed food pantry users had, in particular, a lower consumption of dairy products compared to the general populations. The second review demonstrated that the nutritional quality of reviewed pre-packed food bags provided by food pantries was highly variable within and between included studies. It also showed that the nutritional quality of most of the food bags was low, reflected, in particular, by a low provision of dairy products, vitamins A and C and calcium compared to national recommendations. None of the studies included in the reviews were nationally representative. The third publication showed that the German food bank system Tafel Deutschland provided a comprehensive net of food pantries, social supermarkets, food banks and other services. However, the number of Tafel per 10,000 welfare recipients was lower in eastern Germany (M = 1.37) compared to western Germany ((M = 2.12), t(162.54) = 4.2424, p < 0.0001). In contrast to the results of the studies included in the second review, the Tafel mainly provided perishable food such as fruits and vegetables (41.42% of the amount of food distributed), bakery products (19.85%) and dairy products (13.39%). However, due to the dependence on donors such as retailers, the amount of food distributed varied widely. The assistance of most local Tafel is based on volunteer labor as 89.97% of Tafel’s staff were volunteers. In 79 districts, in which all Tafel participated in the survey, there was an average of 179 Tafel beneficiaries per 1000 welfare recipients and 17 Tafel beneficiaries per 1000 residents overall. An even lower usage was found by the fourth publication which revealed that only two out of 1000 adult inhabitants and six out of 1000 children received assistance from one of the 44 investigated Tafel food pantries in Berlin. Tafel use by adults (A) or by children (B) was related to the percentage of welfare recipients (A, β = 0.17, p < 0.001 und B, β = 0.16, p = 0.002), the percentage of inhabitants with migration background (A, β = - 0.08, p = 0.002), the number of discount grocery percentage stores per 1000 children (B, β = 5.65, p = 0.010), and the number of stops of the public transport within a radius of 500 meters (A, β = - 0.24, p = 0.020). The most important limitation of both studies was the unknown reliability of the data collected from the Tafel. The dietary quality of food pantry users in high-income countries was seen to be low. Although food pantries did not provide a full meal plan for a healthy diet, they may have a positive impact on the dietary quality of its users. However, to better understand the role of food pantries in the complex interplay of individual, social and environmental influences on the diet of food pantry users, multi-level approaches should be used in the future. Moreover, researchers are strongly recommended to investigate the mechanisms by which using a food pantry might impact users’ dietary quality. In addition to these implications for researchers, this thesis makes several recommendations to practitioners at food pantries in Germany and other high-income countries. Following these recommendations could make the position of food pantries in civil society into an important entry point for health promotion among a part of the food insecure population in the future.