Browsing by Subject "Resistance breeding"

Now showing 1 - 10 of 10

Analyzing resistance to ergot caused by Claviceps purpurea [Fr.] Tul. and alkaloid contamination in winter rye (Secale cereale L.)
(2022) Kodisch, Anna; Miedaner, Thomas
Ergot caused by Claviceps purpurea [Fr.] Tul. is one of the oldest well-known plant diseases leading already in medieval times to severe epidemic outbreaks. After the occurrence of honeydew, the characteristic ergot bodies called sclerotia are formed on the ear. These are containing toxic ergot alkaloids (EAs). Strict limits are set within the European Union. Rye (Secale cereale L.) as cross-pollinating crop is particularly vulnerable to ergot since the competitive situation of fungal spores and pollen during flowering. Nevertheless, even today the threat is real as agricultural practice is changing and screening studies revealed EAs in samples of the whole cereal value chain frequently. The aims were to establish a harmonized method to test ergot resistance and EA contamination in winter rye, to clarify major significant factors and their relevance and to reveal the suitability of one commercial ELISA test. Further, effort was paid to examine the covariation of ergot amount and EA content considering different factors because of prospective legislative changes. Genotypes showed significant variation for ergot severity and pollen-fertility restoration after natural infection as well as artificial inoculation whereas a high positive correlation could be found between both treatments. Additionally, variances of environment, general combining ability (GCA), specific combining ability (SCA), and interactions were significant. Although male pollen-fertility restoration was of utmost importance, the female component was also significant. This illustrates that apart from promising selection of high restoration ability the maternal restorability could be exploited in future breeding programs especially when a high pollen amount is already reached. A large-scale calibration study was performed to clarify the covariation of ergot severity, EA content (HPLC, ELISA) considering genotypes, locations, countries, years, and isolates. EA profile was rather stable across country-specific isolates although large differences regarding the EA content were detected. The moderate covariation between ergot severity and EA content (HPLC) indicates that a reliable prediction of the EA content based on ergot severity is not possible what can also not be explained by grouping effects of the factors. Further, EAs seem not to act as virulence factor in the infection process since EA content showed no relationship to disease severity. Additionally, the missing correlation of ELISA and HPLC leads to the conclusion that the ELISA is not an appropriate tool what can be used safely to screen samples regarding ergot in the daily life. The genetic variation of male-sterile CMS-single crosses was analysed in a special design without pollen in field and greenhouse to identify resistance mechanisms and to clarify whether ergot can be reduced in the female flower. At this, comparison of needle and spray inoculation revealed medium to high correlations illustrating that both methods were suitable for this research. Significant environment and genotype by environment interaction variances were detected. So, testing across several environments is necessary also without pollen. Further, small but significant genotypic variation and identification of one more ergot-resilient candidate revealed that selection of female lines could be promising to further reduce ergot. The EA content was lower for less susceptible genotypes. Thus, EA content can be considerably reduced by breeding. A strong positive correlation could be found for ergot severity and EA content when analysing 15 factorial single crosses. The male pollen-fertility restoration was also here the most relevant component but the female component contributed an obviously higher proportion for the EA content than for ergot severity. In conclusion, this thesis demonstrate that implementing of a high and environmental stable male fertility restoration ability via exotic Rf genes can effectively reduce ergot although also the female restorability enables great opportunities. The unpredictable covariation between ergot amount and EA content illustrates that both traits have to be assessed, in particular the EA content by a valid HPLC approach to guarantee food and feed safety.
Anthracnose in white lupin : genetic diversity, virulence and host resistance
(2022) Alkemade, Joris A.; Vögele, Ralf
White lupin (Lupinus albus L.) is a grain legume that is known for its high protein content, nutritional quality, efficient nitrogen fixation and unique ability to form specialized cluster roots that support phosphorus uptake. Despite a severe production decline at the end of the past century, white lupin has seen a recent revival to sustain the demand for plant-based protein and reduce Europe’s dependency on imported soybean. A major problem in (white) lupin cultivation is anthracnose disease, caused by the globally dispersed, seed- and air-borne fungal pathogen Colletotrichum lupini. This PhD thesis aims to provide insights on how to sustainably control anthracnose disease in white lupin in order to support its re-introduction into European cultivation systems. It describes (i) the genetic diversity, phylogeography and virulence of C. lupini, (ii) the development of a high-throughput phenotyping protocol to reliably screen white lupin germplasm, (iii) a genome-wide association study identifying resistance candidate genes and (iv) the exploration of effective seed treatments to reduce the primary pathogen inoculum. Multi-locus phylogeny and morphological characterization of 39 C. lupini isolates showed that diversity is greater than previously reported, distinguishing a total of six genetic groups and ten distinct morphotypes. Highest diversity was found across the South American Andes, indicating it to be the center of origin of C. lupini. Results reveal that the current pandemic is caused by strains belonging to genetic group II, which are spread globally, and are genetically and morphologically uniform. Group II isolates were shown to be highly aggressive on tested white and Andean lupin accessions. Isolates belonging to the other five genetic groups were mostly found locally and showed distinct virulence patterns on both white and Andean lupin accessions. Despite its uniformity, it was shown that two highly virulent group II isolates from Chile could overcome resistance of elite white lupin breeding material, stressing the need to implement phytosanitary protocols for international seed transports. A reliable high-throughput phenotyping tool was developed to identify anthracnose resistance in white lupin germplasm and study pathogen-host interactions. Phenotyping under controlled conditions, performing stem wound inoculation on seedlings, showed to be applicable for high-throughput and its disease scores strongly correlated with two-year Swiss field disease assessments (r = 0.95) and yield (r = -0.64). Phenotyping a diverse set of 40 white lupin accessions revealed eight accessions with improved resistance to anthracnose, which can be incorporated into white lupin breeding programs. A genome-wide association study (GWAS) was done to dissect the genetic architecture for anthracnose resistance in white lupin. White lupin genotypes, collected from the center of domestication and traditional cultivation regions, were screened for anthracnose resistance and characterized through genotyping-by-sequencing (GBS). GWAS revealed two significant SNPs associated with anthracnose resistance on gene Lalb_Chr05_g0216161, encoding a RING zinc-finger E3 ubiquitin ligase potentially involved in plant immunity. Further validation experiments are now required to confirm involvement in plant resistance. Population analysis showed a remarkably fast linkage disequilibrium (LD) decay, weak population structure and grouping of commercial varieties with landraces, corresponding to the slow domestication history and scarce breeding efforts in white lupin. A total of eleven different seed treatments was tested in field trials in Switzerland between 2018 and 2021 to identify treatments that reduce C. lupini infection levels in white lupin. Treatments consisted of hot water, steam, electron, long term storage, vinegar, plant extracts and biological control agents (BCAs). The BCAs were tested under controlled conditions for potential antagonistic activity against C. lupini during white lupin infection prior to field trials. Results showed that long term storage and vinegar treatments can successfully reduce disease incidence and increase yield to levels similar to those observed for certified seeds. In order to sustainably and effectively control anthracnose disease in white lupin, an integrative approach, including modern breeding efforts, disease prevention strategies and mixed cropping systems, is recommended. Further research is required to increase our understanding on white lupin-C. lupini interaction and to identify genetic regions involved in resistance or virulence, respectively, which could greatly support white lupin breeding. This thesis provides the basis to further explore C. lupini population dynamics, virulence and host-speciation, white lupin resistance mechanisms and sustainable ways to control anthracnose disease in order to further facilitate successful white lupin cultivation.
Genetic analysis of resistance to ear rot and mycotoxin contamination caused by Fusarium graminearum in European maize
(2012) Martin, Matthias; Melchinger, Albrecht E.
Maize is affected by a number of diseases. Among the various ear rots of maize, Gibberella ear rot (GER) caused by Fusarium graminearum is prevalent in Central Europe. This fungal pathogen produces secondary metabolites (mycotoxins), which adversely affect the health of humans and animals. Two important mycotoxins are the immunosuppressant deoxynivalenol (DON) and the mycoestrogen zearalenone (ZEA). The most efficient method to reduce mycotoxin contamination in maize is cultivation of resistant varieties. However, resistance breeding using classical phenotypic selection is laborious and time-consuming. Therefore, marker-assisted selection (MAS) may be a promising alternative to classical selection. Furthermore, for setting up a breeding program, knowledge about the relevance of the different modes of gene action and genotypic correlations among resistance and agronomic traits is required. The objectives of this study were to (1) estimate quantitative genetic parameters for GER severity and mycotoxin concentration in connected populations of doubled haploid (DH) lines, (2) map quantitative trait loci (QTL) for GER resistance and reduced mycotoxin contamination in these populations, (3) examine the congruency of QTL in these populations, (4) evaluate the prospects of using MAS to breed for GER resistance and reduced mycotoxin contamination, (5) estimate the genotypic correlation between the resistance of DH lines per se and the resistance of their testcrosses, (6) evaluate the influence of selection for increased resistance on agronomic performance of hybrids and (7) examine the relevance of different modes of gene action involved in the expression of the resistance in flint maize. Three field experiments were conducted, each of which comprised a different set of plant material. Experiment I comprised five DH line populations derived from the following F1 crosses among elite flint inbred lines: D152×UH006, D152×UH007, UH007×UH006, UH009×UH006 and UH009×UH007. Experiment II comprised testcross progenies of 94 DH lines and a dent single cross tester. Experiment III comprised the five F1 crosses, from which the DH populations had been derived, the F2 and the first backcross generations to the parents (BC1-P1, BC1-P2) as well as the two parent lines of each cross. Plants were artificially infected with spores of F. graminearum shortly after mid-silking using the silk channel inoculation technique. The DH lines were genotyped with simple sequence repeat (SSR) DNA markers, genetic linkage maps were constructed and QTL analyses were performed for resistance to GER, DON and ZEA contamination. Estimates of genotypic and genotype-by-environment interaction variances in Experiment I for GER severity and mycotoxin concentration were significant and heritabilities were moderately high to high in all populations. Thus, differences among DH lines for the resistance traits were mainly caused genetically and the resistance response varied depending on the environment. Owing to the effectiveness of artificial inoculation, the prospects are good to improve line resistance using a small number of test environments. QTL were detected in the four largest populations. Depending on the population, the mapped QTL together explained 21-51% of the genotypic variance for GER severity and 19-45% for DON concentration and 52% for ZEA concentration. Additive gene action was more important than digenic interactions of QTL, as indicated by the number of QTL having significant additive effects, their relative contributions to the total genotypic variance explained and the magnitude of their effects. Colocalized QTL for resistance to GER and mycotoxin contamination were identified in each mapping population. This was in agreement with strong genotypic correlations among these traits. QTL located at similar positions were detected across three populations in two chromosomal regions and across two populations in additional two regions. The results of this study indicated that a combination of classical phenotypic selection and MAS is a promising strategy for resistance breeding. In Experiment II, significant genotypic variation for resistance in lines and testcrosses showed that selection will be successful in both groups. Owing to low genotypic correlations between lines and testcrosses, however, resources should be mainly allocated to the evaluation of GER in testcrosses. Correlations of resistance with agronomic traits were weak or not significant. Therefore, selection for resistance and better agronomic performance can be carried out simultaneously. In Experiment III, generation means analysis indicated a prevalence of additive gene action for resistance. Significant dominance effects were found in only one cross for resistance to GER, but in four crosses for resistance to DON contamination. Owing to prevalence of additive gene action, the prospects are good to improve the resistance of the flint germplasm and to accumulate more favorable gene combinations in future breeding lines. Comparing the hybrid performance of flint×flint crosses of Experiment II and flint×dent crosses of Experiment III with their corresponding mid-parent performances indicated mid-parent heterosis for resistance. Therefore, prediction of hybrid performance based on performance of their parents will be possible only to a very limited extent. Future research should focus on fine mapping and validating of the detected QTL. For an efficient use of the QTL in a marker-assisted breeding program, knowledge about their effects in different genetic backgrounds is needed. Of particular importance are thereby the QTL effects in flint×dent crosses, which represent the preferred type of hybrid in Central European maize breeding programs.
Genetische und physiologische Einflußfaktoren sowie deren Wechselwirkungen auf die Trichothecenbildung bei Roggen, Triticale und Weizen nach Inokulation mit Fusarium culmorum (W. G. Sm.) Sacc.
(2002) Reinbrecht, Carsten; Geiger, Hartwig H.
Fusarium culmorum causes specific hazards of cereal quality by the producion of trichothecenes. Prophylaxis by plant breeding can be highly effective. The aim of this study was to investigate the accumulation of trichothecenes in cereals with regard to host and fungal genotype, to physiological factors and the resulting interactions. To determine the effects of 6 environments (E), 2 inoculation dates (ID), 2 fungal isolates (I), and 5 conidia concentrations (C) and their interactions, field trials with up to 12 rye, 6 triticale, and 8 wheat genotypes (G) were conducted in 1995-1997. Kinetics of trichothecene in the heads were described with 6 harvest dates (H) in 2 host genotypes each. In a growth chamber, 2 levels of temperature (T) and 2 of relative humidity (R) were investigated by using 2 host genotypes each. Average deoxynivalenol (DON) accumulation of rye, triticale, and wheat was 41, 46, and 82 mg kg-1, respectively. Genotypes differed significantly in rye and wheat. In all cereal species, GxE interactions were important. In wheat, DON content was highly correlated to all resistance traits, whereas in rye only a tight correlation existed to the relative specific grain weight. In triticale and wheat, inoculation at full anthesis resulted in higher DON contents than inoculation at heading. In rye, no effect of inoculation date was found. In contrast, GxID interaction was significant in rye. The nivalenol (NIV) producing isolate led to lower trichothecene contents than the DON producing isolate. This effect was found to be significant only in rye and triticale. Significant GxI interactions occurred in wheat only. Even one week after inoculation, considerable DON concentrations could be obtained in harvested heads, especially in wheat. Maximum DON contents were observed between 3 and 6 weeks after inoculation (in wheat: partially above 300 mg kg-1). NIV contents were always lower than DON contents. Until full ripening, DON contents slightly decreased, whereas NIV contents increased continuously. HxE and HxI interactions were most important. Trichothecene content in chaff and spindles was 2-4 fold higher than in the respective kernels at 6 and 8 weeks after inoculation. With higher conidia concentrations, increasing contents of DON+3-Acetyl-DON were measured. GxC interactions were highly significant. Highest heritabilities were found in the upper concentration levels. When the relative humidity was high, trichothecene concentrations of kernels were superior. With the temperature, an inverse effect was obtained. It seems that GxT interaction contributed most to GxE in rye and wheat, in triticale also the GxR interaction. In conclusion, assisting resistance traits may replace an expensive quantification of trichothecenes in early generations. In advanced generations, tests should be conducted in several environments with high conidia concentrations, and a toxin analysis should be carried out directly.
Genetische Variation für Resistenz gegen Mutterkorn (Claviceps purpurea [Fr.] Tul.) bei selbstinkompatiblen und selbstfertilen Roggenpopulationen
(2006) Mirdita, Vilson; Miedaner, Thomas
Ergot (Claviceps purpurea [Fr.] Tul.) is one of the most important diseases in rye. Infection during flowering results in the production of black, overwintering organs (sclerotia) instead of kernels, which contain harmful alcaloids. Three experiments were conducted to estimate quantitative-genetic parameters of the resistance of rye to ergot under the conditions of organic farming. The general aim was the estimation of genetic variation among and within self-incompatible rye populations and among CMS lines and their male-sterile testcrosses. In 2002 and 2004, genetic variation in resistance to ergot was tested among 65 rye populations at each of two locations (Experiment 1). Thirteen populations were registered rye varieties and the remaining 52 were genetic resources. To assess genetic variation within populations, 50 full-sib families (FSF) from each of five rye populations were developed and tested at four locations (Experiment 2). To test genetic differences in the susceptibility of ovaries towards fungal penetration in the absence of pollen, (i) 64 currently available CMS lines and (ii) their male-sterile crosses with three testers (=sets) were tested in 2003 and 2004, and in 2004, respectively. Inoculation was performed by spraying an aggressive mixture of isolates of Claviceps purpurea three times during the flowering period. The micro-plots were grown in a chess-board design separated by wheat plots to reduce the neighbouring effects. Traits of resistance were the proportion of infected spikes relative to the total number of spikes per plot, and the percentage by weight of ergot sclerotia in the grain. In Experiment 3, the weight of slcerotia per spike and per pair of spikelet were measured due to the absence of grain. Amount of pollen shedding was rated on the basis of the anther size and extrusion. Highly significant genotypic and genotype-environment interaction variances were found among rye populations in the percentage of ergot sclerotia in the grain. All genotypes were infected by ergot. No differences in mean among the registered rye varieties and genetic resources were detected. Because all populations were highly pollen shedding, the results indicate the existence of genetically determined resistance to ergot within the self-incompatible rye. Correlation between both resistance traits was significant (rp = 0.92). Genetic variation within populations was highly significant for all five populations. Individual progenies with resistance higher than the population mean were observed. The mean resistance of initial populations hardly differed from the mean of their progeny indicating a predominantly additive inheritance. Highly significant genetic variation in resistance to ergot was also detected among the currently available 64 CMS lines. Corresponding testcrosses mostly had a higher weight of sclerotia per spike than the lines. Considerable differences in the level of resistance were observed among testcrosses. Crosses with tester line 1 were substantially more susceptible, whereas those with tester 2 were hardly over the mean of the parental lines. The material showed a quantitative distribution of ergot resistance. Weak to medium-sized correlations (0.33 ? 0.47) between locations were detected among lines. The correlation between locations was even weaker in testcrosses. Weak correlations in ergot weight per spike were observed between CMS lines and their testcrosses in sets 2 and 3. In set 1, the estimated phenotypic correlation was higher (rp = 0.65). Estimates of error-corrected correlations were always higher than phenotypic correlations. No genetic difference was detected among the CMS lines for the amount of alkaloids in their sclerotia. This study shows that incompatible rye populations as well as self-fertile hybrid populations contain a substantial genetic variation for resistance to ergot that is inherited quantitatively. In both materials, mainly additive genetic variance was found. Because of a significant genotype-environment interaction, multi-environment trials are necessary to select for resistance. The results of this study nevertheless indicate good prospects to improve resistance to ergot in rye breeding in the long term.
Genomics-assisted breeding for quantitative disease resistances in small-grain cereals and maize
(2020) Miedaner, Thomas; Boeven, Ana Luisa Galiano-Carneiro; Gaikpa, David Sewodor; Kistner, Maria Belén; Grote, Cathérine Pauline
Generating genomics-driven knowledge opens a way to accelerate the resistance breeding process by family or population mapping and genomic selection. Important prerequisites are large populations that are genomically analyzed by medium- to high-density marker arrays and extensive phenotyping across locations and years of the same populations. The latter is important to train a genomic model that is used to predict genomic estimated breeding values of phenotypically untested genotypes. After reviewing the specific features of quantitative resistances and the basic genomic techniques, the possibilities for genomics-assisted breeding are evaluated for six pathosystems with hemi-biotrophic fungi: Small-grain cereals/Fusarium head blight (FHB), wheat/Septoria tritici blotch (STB) and Septoria nodorum blotch (SNB), maize/Gibberella ear rot (GER) and Fusarium ear rot (FER), maize/Northern corn leaf blight (NCLB). Typically, all quantitative disease resistances are caused by hundreds of QTL scattered across the whole genome, but often available in hotspots as exemplified for NCLB resistance in maize. Because all crops are suffering from many diseases, multi-disease resistance (MDR) is an attractive aim that can be selected by specific MDR QTL. Finally, the integration of genomic data in the breeding process for introgression of genetic resources and for the improvement within elite materials is discussed.
Genomics-assisted breeding strategies for quantitative resistances to Northern corn leaf blight in maize (Zea mays L.) and Fusarium diseases in maize and in triticale (× Triticosecale Wittm.)
(2021) Galiano Carneiro, Ana Luísa; Miedaner, Thomas
Fusarium head blight (FHB) in triticale (× Triticosecale Wittm.), Gibberella ear rot (GER) and Northern corn leaf blight (NCLB) in maize (Zea mays L.) are devastating crop diseases causing yield losses and/or reducing grain quality worldwide. Resistance breeding is the most efficient and sustainable approach to reduce the damages caused by these diseases. For all three pathosystems, a quantitative inheritance based on many genes with small effects has been described in previous studies. Hence, this thesis aimed to assess the potential of genomics-assisted breeding strategies to reduce FHB, GER and NCLB in applied breeding programs. In particular, the objectives were to: (i) Dissect the genetic architecture underlying quantitative variation for FHB, GER and NCLB through different quantitative trait loci (QTL) and association mapping approaches; (ii) assess the potential of genomics-assisted selection to select superior triticale genotypes harboring FHB resistance; (iii) phenotype and characterize Brazilian resistance donors conferring resistance to GER and NCLB in multi-environment trials in Brazil and in Europe; and (iv) evaluate approaches for the introgression and integration of NCLB and GER resistances from tropical to adapted germplasm. The genome-wide association study (GWAS) conducted for FHB resistance in triticale revealed six QTL that reduced damages by 5 to 8%. The most prominent QTL identified in our study was mapped on chromosome 5B and explained 30% of the genotypic variance. To evaluate the potential of genomic selection (GS), we performed a five-fold cross-validation study. Here, weighted genomic selection increased the prediction accuracy from 0.55 to 0.78 compared to the non-weighted GS model, indicating the high potential of the weighted genomic selection approach. The successful application of GS requires large training sets to develop robust models. However, large training sets based on the target trait deoxynivalenol (DON) are usually not available. Due to the rather moderate correlation between FHB and DON, we recommend a negative selection based on genomic estimated breeding values (GEBVs) for FHB severity in early breeding stages. In the long-run, however, we encourage breeders to build and test GS calibrations for DON content in triticale. The genetic architecture of GER caused by Fusarium graminearum in maize was investigated in Brazilian tropical germplasm in multi-environment trials. We observed high genotype-by-environment interactions which requires trials in many environments for the identification of stable QTL. We identified four QTL that explained between 5 to 22% of the genotypic variance. Most of the resistance alleles identified in our study originated from the Brazilian tropical parents indicating the potential of this exotic germplasm as resistance source. The QTL located on chromosome bin 1.02 was identified both in Brazilian and in European trials, and across all six biparental populations. This QTL is likely stable, an important feature for its successful employment across different genetic backgrounds and environments. This stable QTL is a great candidate for validation and fine mapping, and subsequent introgression in European germplasm but possible negative linkage drag should be tackled. NCLB is another economically important disease in maize and the most devastating leaf disease in maize grown in Europe. Virulent races have already overcome the majority of known qualitative resistances. Therefore, a constant monitoring of S. turcica races is necessary to assist breeders on the choice of effective resistances in each target environment. We investigated the genetic architecture of NCLB in Brazilian tropical germplasm and identified 17 QTL distributed along the ten chromosomes of maize explaining 4 to 31% of the trait genotypic variance each. Most of the alleles reducing the infections originated from Brazilian germplasm and reduced NCLB between 0.3 to 2.5 scores in the 1-9 severity scale, showing the potential of Brazilian germplasm to reduce not only GER but also NCLB severity in maize. These QTL were identified across a wide range of environments comprising different S. turcica race compositions indicating race non-specific resistance and most likely stability. Indeed, QTL 7.03 and 9.03/9.04 were identified both in Brazil and in Europe being promising candidates for trait introgression. These major and stable QTL identified for GER and NCLB can be introgressed into elite germplasm by marker-assisted selection. Subsequently, an integration step is necessary to account for possible negative linkage drag. A rapid genomics-assisted breeding approach for the introgression and integration of exotic into adapted germplasm has been proposed in this thesis. Jointly, our results demonstrate the high potential of genomics-assisted breeding strategies to efficiently increase the quantitative resistance levels of NCLB in maize and Fusarium diseases in maize and in triticale. We identified favorable QTL to increase resistance levels in both crops. In addition, we successfully characterized Brazilian germplasm for GER and NCLB resistances. After validation and fine mapping, the introgression and integration of the QTL identified in this study might contribute to the release of resistant cultivars, an important pillar to cope with global food security.
Die Hypersensibilität der Europäischen Pflaume (Prunus domestica L.) gegenüber dem Scharkavirus (Plum pox virus)
(2005) Neumüller, Michael; Wünsche, Jens Norbert
In terms of economic damage, Sharka is the most important virus disease in stone fruit crops. The causative agent of this disease is the Plum pox virus (PPV). Some genotypes of European plum (Prunus domstica L.) show a hypersensitive response when infected with PPV. Results about the inheritance of this type of resistance mediated by hypersensitivity and different types of symptoms characteristic for the hypersensitive defence response in the interavtion PPV/Prunus domestica are presented. From the biochemichal point of view, it is shown that the defence response is indeed a hypersensitive response. A strategy for the development of DNA markers for hypersensitivity to PPV in European plum is developed. The potential use of hypersensitivity for solving the Sharka problem is discussed.
Quantitative-genetic evaluation of resistances to five fungal diseases in a large triticale diversity panel (×Triticosecale)
(2022) Miedaner, Thomas; Flath, Kerstin; Starck, Norbert; Weißmann, Sigrid; Maurer, Hans Peter
The man-made cereal triticale was fully resistant to the biotrophic diseases powdery mildew, leaf rust, yellow rust, and stem rust from its introduction in Europe in the mid-1970s until about 1990. In the following years, new races that were able to infect at least some triticale genotypes developed in all four pathogen populations, and resistance breeding came into focus. Here, we analyzed 656 winter triticale cultivars from 12 countries for resistance to these biotrophic diseases and Fusarium head blight (FHB) at up to 8 location-year combinations (environments). FHB ratings were corrected for plant height and heading stage by comparing three statistical methods. Significant (p < 0.001) genetic variances were found for all resistances with moderate to high entry-mean heritabilities. All traits showed a normal distribution, with the exception of stem rust, where the ratings were skewed towards resistance. There were no substantial correlations among the five disease resistances (r = −0.04 to 0.26). However, several genotypes were detected with multi-disease resistance with a disease rating below average for all five diseases simultaneously. In future, such genotypes must be selected primarily to cope with future challenges of less pesticide use and global climate change.
Resistance breeding in maize (Zea mays L.) against the European corn borer (Ostrinia nubilalis Hübner) and the use of DNA-markers for marker-assisted selection
(2005) Papst, Christine; Melchinger, Albrecht E.
The European corn borer (Ostrinia nubilalis Hb., ECB) is an important pest in maize production. Feeding of ECB larvae causes grain yield losses of up to 30% and promotes ear and stalk rots caused by Fusarium spp.. Maize cultivars carrying the Bt gene are highly resistant to ECB larvae feeding. However, the use of transgenic cultivars is controversially discussed. In contrast, the natural host plant resistance (HPR) is regarded as more durable. The main objective of this study was to identify quantitative trait loci (QTL) for HPR against ECB and to draw conclusions about their usefulness in marker-assisted selection (MAS). The specific research questions were: (1) Where are QTL for ECB resistance and related agronomic traits located in the maize genome and what are their genetic effects? (2) How consistent are QTL detected across unrelated populations? (3) How consistent are QTL detected for line per se and testcross performance? (4) Which physiological mechanisms underlie the resistance against ECB larvae feeding? (5) What is the association between ECB resistance and mycotoxin concentrations in grain maize? Two unrelated dent populations (A and B) were developed. For Experiment 1 the F2:3 families were evaluated for line per se performance for ECB resistance. All F2:3 families of Population B were testcrossed with a susceptible tester line and also evaluated for ECB resistance (Experiment 2). Two sets of F2:3 families from Population B, each comprising the most resistant and the most susceptible lines, were selected (Experiment 3). In Experiment 4, 10 maize cultivars consisting of four pairs of transgenic hybrids and their isogenic counterparts were used to determine the association between mycotoxin concentration and ECB resistance. All entries in Experiment 4 were analyzed for mycotoxin concentration of deoxynivalenol (DON), fumonisin (FUM), fusarenon-X (FUS), moniliformin (MON) and nivalenol (NIV) in grain samples. In all four experiments, resistance to ECB larvae feeding was evaluated using manual infestation with ECB larvae. Furthermore agronomic and quality traits were recorded. In Experiment 1, two QTL for resistance were detected in Population A, both explaining about 25% of the genotypic variance. No common QTL for resistance traits was found across Populations A and B. Possible explanations for the low consistency of QTL across populations are a low power of QTL detection caused by small population sizes, sampling, and environmental effects. Furthermore, population-specific QTL regions cannot be ruled out. In Experiment 2, six QTL for resistance explaining 27% of the genotypic variance were found for testcross performance. Three common QTL for resistance were detected for line per se and testcross performance. Phenotypic as well as genotypic correlations between line per se and testcross performance were low for resistance, indicating a moderate consistency across the different types of progeny. The low consistency across both types of progeny is presumably attributable to the low power of QTL detection in TC progenies caused by a decreased genotypic variance and masking effects of the tester allele. Despite the low consistency of QTL across populations and progenies in the present study, a comparison with other reports from the literature revealed that most of the QTL occurred in clusters. Given the low percentage of genotypic variance explained by QTL-marker associations, we conclude that MAS will not be efficient for resistance breeding against ECB with the current molecular marker techniques. In Experiment 3, significant correlations were observed between resistance and quality traits, such as digestibility and stalk strength. These findings confirm the importance of increased cell-wall fortification for resistance against ECB larvae feeding, and support the hypothesis that candidate genes for resistance are involved in lignin biosynthesis. The analyses of mycotoxin concentrations in Experiment 4 showed that DON, FUM, and MON were the most prevalent mycotoxins in maize kernels. Differences between protected and infested plots were only significant for DON and FUM. Transgenic Bt hybrids showed lower mycotoxin concentrations in kernels than the other hybrids. However, only low correlations were found between ECB resistance and mycotoxin concentrations across all 10 hybrids. Therefore, selection for ECB resistance does not necessarily reduce mycotoxin concentration, suggesting that each complex of characters must be improved simultaneously by breeding. Even if MAS for resistance against the ECB does not seem promising at the moment, the information about QTL regions may be a first step for further research on possible candidate genes, e.g., brown midrib genes located in the common QTL regions with effects on the lignin biosynthesis. Genotypes with an improved digestibility, without impairing ECB resistance by reduced cell-wall strength, would be most promising.